Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
    • Global
    • Nigerian
  • Education
  • Politics
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Europe
    • Finance
    • Nigeria
    • US & Canada
    • World
  • Science
    • Health
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
      • Comedy
      • Ent & Arts
      • Film & Drama
      • Music
      • videos
    • Homes
    • Luxury
    • Media & Culture
  • Sports
  • Others
    • About us
    • Get In Touch

Subscribe to Updates

Get daily mail of the latest news from the Podium Reporters

[email-subscribers-form id="1"]
What's new

Revealed: How Igbo Traders discriminate against other tribes in Alaba International Market, Ojo Lagos

25 March 2023

Tinubu’s election free and fair, sign of Nigeria’s enduring democracy – Washington Post

22 March 2023

Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu

20 March 2023
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Revealed: How Igbo Traders discriminate against other tribes in Alaba International Market, Ojo Lagos
  • Tinubu’s election free and fair, sign of Nigeria’s enduring democracy – Washington Post
  • Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu
  • INEC declares Sanwo-Olu winner of Lagos Guber polls
  • 24 hours to Lagos Guber polls, leadership dispute over LP ‘legitimate’ candidate lingers
  • FIRS Signs MoU with UK’s HM Revenue and Customs For Collaboration On Capacity Building
  • NASS leadership: Group roots for Hon. Sada Soli as Reps Speaker
  • Leaked letter from Tinubu’s camp shows president-elect wants to build bridges, reconcile aggrieved individuals
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Sunday, March 26
Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
Demo
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
    • Global
    • Nigerian
  • Education
  • Politics
    1. Asia
    2. Africa
    3. Europe
    4. Finance
    5. Nigeria
    6. US & Canada
    7. World
    8. View All

    ISWAP KINGPINS ALI KWAYA, BUKAR MAINOKA AND OTHERS NEUTRALIZED IN NAF AIR STRIKES AT BELOWA NEAR LAKE CHAD

    7 November 2022

    End of the road for Odinga as Supreme Court affirms Ruto’s victory

    5 September 2022

    Gov. Sanwo-Olu named Tuberculosis eradication champion, rolls out state plans for TB

    26 August 2022

    Ghana Cedi confirmed world’s worst-performing currency as country battles worsening economic crisis

    18 August 2022

    Breaking: Queen Elizabeth II is dead

    8 September 2022

    Naira redesign to have positive impact on the economy – Experts

    27 October 2022

    FG will stop paying petrol subsidy June 2023 – Minister

    22 August 2022

    Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu

    20 March 2023

    INEC declares Sanwo-Olu winner of Lagos Guber polls

    20 March 2023

    24 hours to Lagos Guber polls, leadership dispute over LP ‘legitimate’ candidate lingers

    17 March 2023

    ‘Defeat, part of politics; perish thought of self-exile’, Tinubu tells Bode George

    15 March 2023

    Ogun Amotekun arrest man with bloodstained pants

    13 October 2022

    UNGA77: I’ll leave behind credible election in 2023 – Buhari 

    22 September 2022

    Buhari pays tribute to Queen Elizabeth II

    9 September 2022

    Tinubu’s election free and fair, sign of Nigeria’s enduring democracy – Washington Post

    22 March 2023

    Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu

    20 March 2023

    INEC declares Sanwo-Olu winner of Lagos Guber polls

    20 March 2023

    24 hours to Lagos Guber polls, leadership dispute over LP ‘legitimate’ candidate lingers

    17 March 2023
  • Science
    1. Health
    2. View All

    Kogi Reference Hospital: Yahaya Bello’s Pure Genius

    28 April 2022

    Kwara hosts 22 APC States’ meeting on improving healthcare access

    26 August 2021

    Distinction: Sanwo-Olu Gets A+ Rating In Covid-19, Security, Infrastructure – Report

    10 August 2021

    Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu’s Coronavirus Press Statement

    11 July 2021

    FACT CHECK: Video of Elon Musk endorsing Obi fake, part of dangerous disinformation campaign

    31 August 2022

    Metaverse ecosystem market to hit $2t by 2030

    3 August 2022

    Navigating Virtual Market in an African Context by Babatunde Adekanmbi

    10 July 2022

    Kogi Reference Hospital: Yahaya Bello’s Pure Genius

    28 April 2022
  • Lifestyle
    1. Entertainment
    2. Comedy
    3. Ent & Arts
    4. Film & Drama
    5. Music
    6. videos
    7. Homes
    8. Luxury
    9. Media & Culture
    10. View All

    ‘I want my old life back’, BBNaija star, Phyna cries out

    15 March 2023

    Cubana Chief Priest endorses Sanwo-Olu for second term

    6 March 2023

    I didn’t collect money from any candidate — Toyin Abraham

    21 February 2023

    Rema returns with two new songs for 2023

    17 February 2023

    Photos: Banky W, Adesua finally reveal son

    17 September 2022

    SSANU, NASU call off strike after meeting with FG

    20 August 2022

    Sanwo-Olu Inspects 1,188-unit Sangotedo Housing Project, Sets Deadlines for Commissioning

    17 September 2021

    Did you know? – Perfumery edition

    10 August 2022

    Do You Know Who Wore the First Lipstick?

    10 August 2022

    Nigeria’s database increased by 150% in three years, Pantami recounts success of NIM

    17 September 2022

    Nigeria, Qatar set for partnership over cultural promotion

    7 September 2022

    Ooni of Ife marries new wife, Mariam

    7 September 2022

    FACT CHECK: Video of Elon Musk endorsing Obi fake, part of dangerous disinformation campaign

    31 August 2022

    ‘I want my old life back’, BBNaija star, Phyna cries out

    15 March 2023

    Cubana Chief Priest endorses Sanwo-Olu for second term

    6 March 2023

    I didn’t collect money from any candidate — Toyin Abraham

    21 February 2023

    Rema returns with two new songs for 2023

    17 February 2023
  • Sports
  • Others
    • About us
    • Get In Touch
Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
Home » News » Fiscally Speaking: the VAT Question and a Few Answers
Business Updated:5 August 2022

Fiscally Speaking: the VAT Question and a Few Answers

By Adekunle15 September 2021No Comments0 Views6 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp

The buzz of VAT and its administration has captured the headlines of most blogs and newspapers in Nigeria. At the centre of the conversation is the Rivers State Governor, Nyesom Wike, pushing forward a VAT law that seeks to collect Value Added Tax from Rivers businesses as against paying to the Federal Government. Backing him is the judgment of a Federal High Court that declared the collection of VAT by the Federal Government illegal, and empowered Rivers State to do so.

Another state is joining in: Lagos. And if newspaper headlines are anything to go by, more States who see a pie to be eaten from VAT gains would join too.

But this judgment is seen as odd to many: after over two decades of VAT administration saddled in the hands of the Federal Government, it suddenly has become illegal? On what basis has the Federal Government then carried out this now illegal act?

Can the VAT Act, a Federal Legislation passed by the National Assembly now become impotent and subservient to State law on the same matter? Does this Act become inapplicable because VAT is not expressly mentioned in the constitution? That should not be so. The powers of the National Assembly to make laws on tax matters are not limited to just those in the Exclusive and Residual lists.

Another question that has been asked by legal commentators is this: How come this judgment now, when some years ago, the Supreme Court gave its blessing to the VAT Act as being above and superior to similar legislation that Lagos State was proposing then. It quashed that Lagos law then.

Similarly, a Federal High Court in Kogi State said that the FIRS was the sole collector of VAT taxes and not the State. Two courts of coordinate jurisdiction have given different pronouncements on the same matter. Sadly, taxpayers would be the victims of the confusion. The hope they have now is the order of the Court of Appeal stating that the parties to the case must not give any effect to the weird judgment of the Federal High Court that sat in Port Harcourt, Rivers State and that the status quo ante bellum be maintained.

Questions were rife when the judgment first surfaced. For one, businessmen in Rivers were already confused as to whether they were to pay their VAT to Rivers state or the Federal Government, even when their headquarters are situated in other states. When they shared these concerns with the Governor during a stakeholder conference he held with them, he had no answers for them.

Then there is also the question of the technical input and output mechanism that defines why VAT as a goods and service tax across the globe has remained a matter left for the national and not the sub-national units.

The outcome of the FIRS application for stay of proceedings at the Court of Appeal if granted would only hold effect till the final determination of the matter. That final determination is eagerly awaited, to ease the needless tension this political and economic confusion has brought to taxpayers.

If it ever happens, the domino effect of states collecting VAT as against the Federal Government, which equitably shares it amongst the three tiers of government, would be felt strongly. Some states would be at the bad end of the stick and would end up running back to the Federal Government. The financial status of any state that thinks collecting VAT by itself would make it richer may not change as much as it thinks.

For instance, the argument that some have made saying that Lagos generates the most VAT is inchoate. What those who make this postulation do not tell you is that Lagos fetches the most VAT because it enjoys the “Headquarters Effect,” such that a business that transacts all across the country pays no VAT in those places it transacts in, but pays it where its Headquarters is situated: Lagos. If these businesses were to pay VAT across the country, in the places they make their money, the myth of the Lagos jumbo VAT would be crushed.

Nigeria is primarily a federation: it is a union, and unions join together, bringing the strengths of each unit to bolster a common front. A powerful country with strong sub-national units is the goal. Not extremities of competing states against each other. Yes, while many states are not as economically strong as others, the strength of a Federation is not limited to just each unit working to attain maximum economic capacity but extends to providing strength to weak states equitably so that they can grow and meet up.

So when farm produce harvested in the farms of Jigawa or Benue, are processed in the industries of Ogun and Oyo State, with VAT being charged to the final product from Ogun and Oyo, we see states bringing their strengths together for the good of the nation, while not belaboring taxpayers at each point of economic activity. If States, where food crops were to be harvested, decide to tax them at source, coupled with VAT paid on the final items, the cost of food items would skyrocket.

Ultimately, were the VAT collection to be positioned in the states and the Federal Government too, the winner would be the Federal Government, which already rakes in a big chunk of the collected sum from VAT paid in the Federal Capital Territory and that collected from imported goods. That does no good to the Federation. States lose at the end.

The Federal Government, through the FIRS already has a strong and capable collection framework. It is better placed than States to do this. Its contested 4% collection charge is little compared to the work that its machinery uses to ensure an effective, smooth, and accurate collection of these funds—such that none of it ends up in the hands of unruly thugs or corrupt officers.

Nigeria, as a whole, has more to benefit from VAT administration operated from the Centre. Citizens do not want annoying double-taxation on goods that would be suffered when states begin to pass individual and irregular VAT laws for themselves. Already, the proposed VAT percentage by Rivers State differs from that Lagos is proposing. Moreover, the current structure works for the equitable distribution of resources: states bringing more to the table still get so much; economically weaker states get just enough too. For instance, Rivers State which brought in about 43 Billion Naira into the VAT pool in 2020, took back 40 Billion Naira as its allocation.

Political leaders, as they enter into the debate of what works best should think win-win for the country. A dog-eat-dog approach on the VAT question would not augur well for the citizens in the long run. When a federation is at war with itself, nobody wins.

Mohammad T. Abiodun, a historian writes from Abuja.

Business Economic economy TAX VAT
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Email WhatsApp

Related Posts

06 Views

Tinubu’s election free and fair, sign of Nigeria’s enduring democracy – Washington Post

22 March 20232 Mins Read
03 Views

Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu

20 March 20233 Mins Read
00 Views

INEC declares Sanwo-Olu winner of Lagos Guber polls

20 March 20231 Min Read
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Demo
Top Posts

EXCLUSIVE: Obi agrees to deal to clear path for Atiku’s emergence

26 August 202222K Views

“We have no record of crime against Tinubu” – US declares, falsifies drug dealing allegations

8 November 202211K Views

“Yorubas are from lineage of traitors and cowards, will soon be landless” – Kennena Eloka, prominent Obi supporter, fumes on social media

8 October 20227K Views

Uproar as Obi demands over N1M in gate fees to address Nigerians

4 September 20226K Views
Lifestyle
Entertainment

‘I want my old life back’, BBNaija star, Phyna cries out

By Victor Fola15 March 20232 Views

Big Brother Naija Season 7 winner, Ijeoma Josephina Otabor aka Phyna has yearned for her…

Cubana Chief Priest endorses Sanwo-Olu for second term

6 March 2023

I didn’t collect money from any candidate — Toyin Abraham

21 February 2023

Rema returns with two new songs for 2023

17 February 2023
Find us on social media folow
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from us.

Demo
About
About

It is our belief that the growth of any society depends on the quality of its journalism. We live up to this ideal by providing factual and full information on politics, sports, entertainment and culture so citizens can make informed decisions and act in defence of the truth.

Facebook Twitter
Recommended

Revealed: How Igbo Traders discriminate against other tribes in Alaba International Market, Ojo Lagos

25 March 20231 Min Read

Tinubu’s election free and fair, sign of Nigeria’s enduring democracy – Washington Post

22 March 20232 Mins Read

Victory not just mine, but every Lagosian — Sanwo-Olu

20 March 20233 Mins Read
Most Popular

EXCLUSIVE: Obi agrees to deal to clear path for Atiku’s emergence

26 August 202222K Views

“We have no record of crime against Tinubu” – US declares, falsifies drug dealing allegations

8 November 202211K Views

“Yorubas are from lineage of traitors and cowards, will soon be landless” – Kennena Eloka, prominent Obi supporter, fumes on social media

8 October 20227K Views
© 2023 The Podium Reporters. Designed by Marvelworx Limited.
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
  • Politics
  • Science
  • Sports

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.