Close Menu
Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
    • Global
    • Nigerian
  • Education
  • Politics
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Europe
    • Finance
    • Nigeria
    • US & Canada
    • World
  • Science
    • Health
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
      • Comedy
      • Ent & Arts
      • Film & Drama
      • Music
      • videos
    • Homes
    • Luxury
    • Media & Culture
  • Sports
  • Others
    • About us
    • Get In Touch
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • Navy’s Intervention in Delta State School Highlights Commitment to Social Responsibility
  • Trump’s Tariff Barrage: Canada Targeted with 35% Duty Amid Broader Trade Offensive
  • Opposition Parties Unite Under ADC Banner to Challenge Tinubu’s APC in 2027
  • Tinubu Administration’s Policy Reforms Yield Positive Economic Indicators, Says Information Minister
  • LASIEC Stands Firm: Ballot Box Snatching to Trigger Fresh Polls in Lagos LG Elections
  • Local Government Autonomy: One Year After Supreme Court Ruling, States Hold the Purse Strings
  • FIFA Rankings Update Sees Nigeria’s Super Eagles Drop One Spot Amid Global Shifts
  • Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan’s Chairmanship Ends as Senate Appoints Aniekan Bassey to Diaspora Committee
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Friday, July 11
Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
Demo
  • Home
  • News
  • Economy
    • Global
    • Nigerian
  • Education
  • Politics
    1. Asia
    2. Africa
    3. Europe
    4. Finance
    5. Nigeria
    6. US & Canada
    7. World
    8. View All

    Korea-Africa Summit: Has a new chapter opened in South Korea-Africa Relations?

    9 June 2024

    Aregbesola Champions Easier Path to Naturalisation, Announces Brown Card For Permanent Residency 

    28 May 2023

    Amnesty International’s Report: A Fictional Drama Masquerading as Human Rights Work

    29 May 2025

    A Word of Caution to the Nigerian Public: Don’t Fall for the Traore Fake Hype

    5 May 2025

    Nigeria’s Golden Deal That Few Are Talking About

    23 March 2025

    AU Endorses Nigeria as AfCFTA Digital Trade Champion

    17 February 2025

    UK-based Obidient, Oluomo of Derby accused of turning “Nigerians in UK” group into personal company; rakes in over £100k in secret deals

    24 January 2025

    Ukraine hits Russian city and oil refinery on day two of presidential vote

    16 March 2024

    SpaceX Ventures into Spy Satellite Network in Classified Deal with U.S. Intelligence

    16 March 2024

    Breaking: Queen Elizabeth II is dead

    8 September 2022

    Why I Share in Wale Edun’s Optimism On The Nigerian Economy 

    17 February 2025

    Facts, figures and dynamics of petroleum products pricing in Nigeria

    4 August 2024

    President Tinubu sacks Aisha Buhari’s brother as MD Nigerian Security, Printing and Minting Plc

    11 July 2024

    Standard Chartered Bank pledges to invest in Lagos-Calabar coastal road, PH-Maiduguri rail project

    25 June 2024

    Amnesty International’s Report: A Fictional Drama Masquerading as Human Rights Work

    29 May 2025

    Ambassador Tuggar’s Quiet Rebuilding of Nigeria’s Global Standing

    27 May 2025

    Why Maj Gen AE Abubakar is the Right Choice to Lead Northeast Counter-Insurgency Operations

    29 April 2025

    Governor Okphebolo orders crackdown on cult-related violence in Edo State

    29 April 2025

    BREAKING NEWS: Trump returns as US President with a projected 312 electoral votes; Kamala cancels victory party

    6 November 2024

    Toronto Police arrests Amaka Sunnberger over threats to poison Yoruba and Benin people

    2 September 2024

    SpaceX Ventures into Spy Satellite Network in Classified Deal with U.S. Intelligence

    16 March 2024

    U.S. Federal Authorities Investigate Meta Platforms for Suspected Involvement in Drug Sales on Social Media

    16 March 2024

    BREAKING: Pope Francis dies at the age of 88

    21 April 2025

    International Relations Amidst Global Uncertainty

    20 April 2025

    At Chatham House, Ambassador Yusuf Tuggar Makes Case For Nigeria’s Strategic Foreign Policy Priorities

    6 March 2025

    US Congressman, Scott Perry said USAID funded Boko Haram, al-Qaeda, ISIS

    14 February 2025

    Opposition Parties Unite Under ADC Banner to Challenge Tinubu’s APC in 2027

    11 July 2025

    Crisis Deepens in Labour Party as Peter Obi Faces Expulsion Over Coalition Support

    8 July 2025

    Presidency Accused of Destabilizing ADC as Opposition Coalition Faces Legal and Internal Struggles

    8 July 2025

    How Malami was fingered in $497 million Ajaokuta deal, $200 million Mambilla deal and $418 million Paris Club consultancy deal

    7 July 2025
  • Science
    1. Health
    2. View All

    Ogun State First Lady Partners with US Surgeons to Provide Free Healthcare Services

    10 July 2025

    FG Disburses N32bn to Boost Primary Healthcare Services Nationwide

    2 July 2025

    FG converts Gombe General Hospital to a Federal Medical Centre

    9 March 2025

    President Tinubu subsidises dialysis and radiotherapy costs for Nigerian patients

    6 March 2025

    Ogun State First Lady Partners with US Surgeons to Provide Free Healthcare Services

    10 July 2025

    Governor Dapo Abiodun Challenges Ogun Youths to Embrace ICT as ‘Window on America’ Opens

    4 July 2025

    FG Disburses N32bn to Boost Primary Healthcare Services Nationwide

    2 July 2025

    Nationwide Mobile Network Operators Brace for Temporary SIM Service Disruptions Due to NIMC Platform Upgrade

    1 July 2025
  • Lifestyle
    1. Entertainment
    2. Comedy
    3. Ent & Arts
    4. Film & Drama
    5. Music
    6. videos
    7. Homes
    8. Luxury
    9. Media & Culture
    10. View All

    VIDEO: NDLEA Warns Travellers Against Carrying Unfamiliar Luggage Amid Rising Drug Smuggling Cases

    29 June 2025

    Real Warri Pikin Honors Husband’s Fatherhood in Moving Social Media Tribute on Father’s Day

    15 June 2025

    Nigerian Star Tems to Lead First-Ever FIFA Club World Cup Final Halftime Performance

    10 June 2025

    Nasboi’s Determined Journey to Collaborate with Davido Interrupted by Accident

    4 June 2025

    Soyinka @ 90: President Tinubu renames National Theatre, Lagos to Wole Soyinka Center of Culture and Creative Arts

    12 July 2024

    God ordained Tinubu to be President of Nigeria – Oba of Benin

    27 November 2023

    Photos: Banky W, Adesua finally reveal son

    17 September 2022

    Nigerian Star Tems to Lead First-Ever FIFA Club World Cup Final Halftime Performance

    10 June 2025

    Renewed Hope Concert puts Nigeria in celebratory mood as excited youths look forward to Tinubu’s swearing-in

    26 May 2023

    VIDEO: NDLEA Warns Travellers Against Carrying Unfamiliar Luggage Amid Rising Drug Smuggling Cases

    29 June 2025

    VOXPOP Reviews: Public and Students of National Open University on Newly Signed Student Loan Scheme by President Bola Ahmed Tinubu

    3 April 2024

    BREAKING: President Bola Tinubu has officially approved and signed the amendment bill for national student loans into law.

    3 April 2024

    Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan’s Chairmanship Ends as Senate Appoints Aniekan Bassey to Diaspora Committee

    10 July 2025

    President Tinubu’s Vision for Food Sovereignty Drives New Agricultural and Industrial Initiatives

    10 July 2025

    Abdullahi Ganduje Takes Helm as Chairman of Nigeria’s Federal Airports Authority Board

    9 July 2025

    Dangote Lauds Tinubu’s Flood Control and Infrastructure Initiatives as Models of Visionary Governance

    9 July 2025

    Did you know? – Perfumery edition

    10 August 2022

    Do You Know Who Wore the First Lipstick?

    10 August 2022

    “I’m disappointed in you for not celebrating Ooni of Ife at 50” – Yoruba Obidient berates Obi

    20 October 2024

    First Lady Oluremi Tinubu unveils national unity fabric

    16 September 2024

    Rufai Oseni attacks Arise TV Boss, Nduka Obaigbena, others over looted funds

    11 August 2024

    President Tinubu’s ADC installed as traditional ruler in Kwara community

    12 July 2024

    Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan’s Chairmanship Ends as Senate Appoints Aniekan Bassey to Diaspora Committee

    10 July 2025

    President Tinubu’s Vision for Food Sovereignty Drives New Agricultural and Industrial Initiatives

    10 July 2025

    Abdullahi Ganduje Takes Helm as Chairman of Nigeria’s Federal Airports Authority Board

    9 July 2025

    Dangote Lauds Tinubu’s Flood Control and Infrastructure Initiatives as Models of Visionary Governance

    9 July 2025
  • Sports
  • Others
    • About us
    • Get In Touch
Podium ReportersPodium Reporters
Home » News » Why Atiku’s Certificate Fishing Expedition to Chicago State University is Useless
News

Why Atiku’s Certificate Fishing Expedition to Chicago State University is Useless

By Michael Chibuzo13 September 2023No Comments8 Views7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp

 

Alhaji Atiku Abubakar filed a lawsuit in a US District Court in Illinois, requesting that Chicago State University (CSU) release all of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s academic records in their custody as he attempts to prove alleged irregularities in the certificate President Tinubu submitted to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC). Atiku first made this request through a subpoena application under the US Statute 28 USC §1782 for discovery of documents.

Atiku’s lawyers are arguing that they need the court to compel CSU to turn over all the records they are requesting about President Tinubu to them so as to help Atiku prove that the discrepancy between the copy of the certificate President Tinubu submitted to INEC last year and the copy of the certificate a Nigerian lawyer practicing in the US, Mike Enahoro-Ebah got from CSU via an alleged subpoena from a US Court.

The Atiku camp also believe that the error in the year written on the replacement certificate CSU issued to Tinubu was a confirmation that President Bola Tinubu did not graduate from CSU and that he forged the certificate he submitted to INEC in June 2022. Most importantly, Atiku is arguing that the discovery of the records he is requesting from CSU will aid him in his ongoing case at the PEPC back in Nigeria against the election of President Bola Tinubu.

Now let me drop the following key points:

1. The ONLY reason there seems to be two versions of President Tinubu’s Certificate is because Mike Enahoro-Ebah used a forged court subpoena and misled CSU to create a copy of President Tinubu’s diploma certificate and issue to him.

Atiku then listed Mike Enahoro-Ebah as one of his Expert Witness and used him to tender the fraudulently procurred certificate from CSU. This certificate tendered by Atiku through Mike Enahoro-Ebah has different font, seal and signatories from the replacement certificate CSU issued to President Bola Tinubu.

2. Atiku Abubakar lied to the US Court when he said in his application to the court that he needed the academic records of President Bola Tinubu from CSU to prove his case at the election petition tribunal in Nigeria.

The truth is that in the Atiku petition at the Tribunal, he did not challenge the academic qualifications of President Bola Tinubu. In ground 4 of his petition, Atiku simply stated in his paragraph 146 that “as at the time of the election, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu was not qualified to contest the election, not having the constitutional threshold.” He did not provide further particulars to back up this ground neither did he state the exact Constitutional threshold that President Bola Tinubu failed to meet.

As a I mentioned in my article dissecting the Atiku petition, Atiku Abubakar only listed four documents in his List of Documents to be relied upon in the petition and none of them is Tinubu’s CSU diploma certificate. They only brought it through the back door during their reply to the Statement of Defence of the Respondents, which is illegal because it has been settled by the Supreme Court that a petitioner cannot introduce new facts into his petition during a reply as that will not give the Respondent fair hearing since at that point they cannot respond to the new facts smuggled in.

Atiku essentially sought to spring a surprise and the Justices of the PEPC dealt with them adequately by STRIKING OUT both the portions of their reply where Atiku sought to bring in the academic records of President Tinubu as particulars to support their ground 4. They cited the judgment of Nnaemeka-Agu JSC, in Atanda vs Ajani part of which stated that “the rule which required every fact upon which a party intends to rely at the hearing to be pleaded goes to the fundamentals of justice. For no one can defend the unknown. If one has to defend or counter a fact made by his adversary, the one must have due notice of that fact to enable him prepare for his defence.”

The CTC of President Tinubu’s diploma certificate, which Atiku’s star witness (and final witness) at the PEPC, Mike Enahoro-Ebah got from CSU using a fraudulent court subpoena and which Atiku tendered at the tribunal while leading him in evidence during hearing was also STRUCK OUT alongside all other documents they tendered through him because they amounted to belated amendment of their petition.

What this means is that the academic qualification of President Bola Tinubu was and is not an issue for determination before the court abinitio and therefore even if Atiku appeals to the Supreme Court, the issue of Tinubu’s academic records will not be up for appeal! This basically renders the Atiku voyage to Chicago useless because the US Statute 28 USC §1782 tool is only invoked by parties from foreign countries outside the US who have pending court cases in their home country or planning to institute one.

Atiku cannot institute a new election petition in Nigeria and the one he filed before PEPC, for which judgment has been delivered against him, do not contain Tinubu’s diploma certificate as an issue and therefore ineligible for inclusion during any potential appeal. The US District Court of Illinois will therefore declined his application.

3. President Bola Ahmed Tinubu is not in any way guilty of any certificate forgery. It has been established repeatedly by Chicago State University that Bola A. Tinubu graduated from CSU in 1979 and bagged a Diploma in Business Administration with Honours. The fact that Mike Enahoro-Ebah still got a certified copy of Tinubu’s replacement diploma certificate even if it is through a deceptive means, confirms that President Bola Tinubu was indeed a student of the University.

4. The disparity in the certificate issued by CSU to both President Tinubu and Mike Enahoro-Ebah has been explained by the Chicago State University through an affidavit where they clearly stated that all diploma certificates (including certified copies and replacement certificates) are SIGNED BY THE CURRENT PRESIDENT/BOARD CHAIR of the University when the request was made.

The University also clarified that the difference in font type and seal seen on different diplomas issued by institution at various times is simply because the university updates its fonts and seal. CSU also made it clear that in the US, institutions of higher education often consider diploma to be a CEREMONIAL DOCUMENT that confirms the attainment of education based on records, which the university keep for each of its student.

What the above means is that CSU keeps records of only the records of students’ academic output and not the records of the ceremonial documents it gives to them to certify completion of academic programme in the school. Therefore, many of Atiku’s request are not possible because CSU does not keep those records. They cannot produce what they do not keep.

5. Finally, CSU has clarified that error in the date on the certificate issued to President Tinubu is a clerical error from their typist as details of students are entered manually by a university personnel and therefore prone to mistakes.

It therefore smirks of foolhardy and unbridled desperation for Atiku to be fishing on a rocky mountain. You do not prove forgery by showing differences in certificates, which the owner has explained. A maker of a document is always the best person to authenticate the document before a court. Atiku mischievously did not include alleged forgery of certificate in their petition, which would have warranted them to subpoena CSU to come and vouch for the authenticity of the certificate.

This fishing expedition in the US by Atiku is simply a tragicomedy taken too far. They will come back empty handed with eyes crestfallen. You do not build something on nothing!

Atiku Abubakar Chicago State University Mike Enahoro-Ebah President Bola Tinubu
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Email WhatsApp

Related Posts

01 Views

Navy’s Intervention in Delta State School Highlights Commitment to Social Responsibility

11 July 20251 Min Read
04 Views

Opposition Parties Unite Under ADC Banner to Challenge Tinubu’s APC in 2027

11 July 20252 Mins Read
01 Views

LASIEC Stands Firm: Ballot Box Snatching to Trigger Fresh Polls in Lagos LG Elections

11 July 20252 Mins Read
Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

© 2025 The Podium Reporters. Designed by Marvelworx Limited.
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
  • Politics
  • Science
  • Sports

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.